Keurig K-Classic vs K-Select: Which Is Better? [2023]

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure for more info.

Finding the best Keurig is simple – it’s all about a few key features. Let’s dive into what sets the Keurig K-Classic apart from the K-Select.

Quick Comparison: K-Classic vs K-Select

Important Keurig Features

Cup size selection

Explore the world of Keurig coffee cup sizes, where you can pick from up to five different serving sizes, from a tiny 4 ounces to a generous 12 ounces. But, if you’re using one of the smaller machines like the K-Mini, K-Mini Plus, or K-Slim, there’s no need to choose. Simply fill the water reservoir, and these clever devices will brew the perfect amount of coffee just for you.

All Keurig models use the same pod size, affecting the taste based on the brew size. Typically, flavors stay rich up to 8 ounces. At 10 ounces, most coffee fans might find it less flavorful, while a 12-ounce cup might seem too diluted for those who love a strong coffee kick.

Drip coffee and carafe

The K-Duo Keurigs are amazing! Not only can they whip up a single cup of coffee, but they can also make a whole carafe of drip coffee. You can choose to brew 8, 10, or 12 cups at once. Plus, except for the K-Essentials, they can even do 6 cups. Perfect for any coffee need!

Some coffee machines, like the K-Duo and K-Duo Essentials, come with a typical glass pot, just like the ones you see on regular coffee makers. But, the K-Duo Plus is a bit special – it has a stainless-steel thermal pot that keeps your coffee warm for hours, without that burnt taste you get when coffee sits too long on a warmer.

Water tank

Every Keurig comes with a water tank, but the size changes depending on the model. Smaller ones like the K-Mini series hold enough for a single cup, while bigger models like the K-Supreme Plus can make up to 9 regular cups or 13 small cups before needing a refill. Perfect for any coffee lover’s needs!

Newer Keurig models come with detachable water tanks, making refills a breeze. Plus, you can easily wash the tank in your sink, keeping your coffee taste fresh!

The K-Supreme and K-Duo Plus coffee makers come with a cool feature: a movable water tank! You can slide it to the side or tuck it behind, making these brewers a perfect fit for any kitchen, especially if you’re tight on space.

Strong button

Old Keurigs brewed weak coffee, but not anymore! Now, with the Keurig strong button, even those craving a bolder cup can enjoy their perfect brew.

Pressing the strong button adds about 30 seconds to your coffee brewing. This extra bit of time lets the water soak up more oils, acids, and sugars from the coffee grounds, making your cup taste way better.

This feature is essential for drip coffee lovers. Learn more here.

Temperature control

Most Keurigs heat water to 192°F to make your coffee. However, models like the K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus let you adjust the temperature slightly. The K-Elite lets you choose between 187-192°F. The K-Supreme Plus also has temperature options, but it doesn’t tell you the exact numbers. 

This feature adds a nice touch for certain drinks, though many might not find it very useful.

Iced coffee

Turning hot coffee into iced coffee by just adding ice might seem easy, but it often leads to a diluted taste. Sadly, even using the ‘strong’ setting on a Keurig doesn’t prevent the coffee from becoming too watered-down.

Explore iced coffee perfection with K-Elite, K-Supreme models – all designed with a special iced coffee feature.

Just like the special iced coffee option on top Ninja coffee machines, this cool feature makes your coffee hot and strong. Why? So when you add ice, your coffee still tastes amazing and full of flavor, instead of watered down. Perfect for iced coffee lovers!

Lattes and cappuccinos

Dive into the world of lattes and cappuccinos with the Keurig K-Cafe and K-Latte! Not just for regular coffee, these machines come with a handy milk frother – stainless steel for the K-Cafe and non-stick plastic for the K-Latte. Perfect for beginners!

They use regular k-cup pods and the frothers work with all milk types.

MultiStream technology

Keurig’s new MultiStream technology is their biggest upgrade since the strong button, making your coffee even richer and more flavorful.

Keurigs use pressure to push water through the middle of a k-cup, but often miss the edges. This means some delicious coffee flavor gets left behind, not making it into your cup.

MultiStream technology transforms your coffee by using several streams of water to soak the coffee pod evenly. This method makes sure every coffee ground is used, giving you a richer, more delicious cup of coffee.

Switching from a classic coffee maker? Try the K-Supreme series with MultiStream technology. They’ll elevate your coffee game way beyond other Keurigs.

Fits travel mug

In the past, fitting a travel mug under older Keurig models was a struggle. But worry no more! Today’s Keurigs are designed to fill your travel mug right up, hassle-free.


Nearly every Keurig now comes with a cool auto-off feature. It turns off the machine to save power, either 5 minutes or 2 hours later, based on the model.

Keurig K-Classic

The Keurig K-Classic is the latest basic model, taking over from the beloved K-40 and K-50 series. These simple machines set the standard for Keurig’s look and feel.

The K-Classic brews tastier coffee and is sturdier than older versions. But, it misses many cool features that newer Keurig models have.

If you love the classic Keurig style but want something simple, the K-Classic is your go-to. For those craving more bells and whistles in a similar look, the K-Select and K-Elite are worth exploring.

Keurig K-Select

The Keurig K-Select sits comfortably in the middle of Keurig’s top models. It steps up from the K-Classic with a cool feature – a strong button. This button slows down brewing by 30 seconds for a richer taste. Plus, it has a bigger water tank and offers a 12-ounce cup option, perfect for your morning coffee.

Final Verdict

The “strong” button makes Keurig coffee taste much better. If it fits your budget (and it’s not too pricey), I highly suggest choosing the K-Select instead of the K-Classic.

If you find most machines too big for your kitchen or crave even tastier coffee, consider the Keurig K-Supreme and K-Supreme Plus. They’re a significant upgrade from the popular K-Classic, promising superior coffee experiences.

keurig k classic vs k select

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *